Oct 6, 2026 | 4 min read
California EPR Penalties: What If Your Winery Doesn’t File
Written by Jeanette Tan | Photo by Unsplash
“I’ll deal with it when I have to”
Many owners of small, family wineries have heard about California’s EPR Program but are kicking the can down the road. Between challenging sales trends, challenging weather (and fires) during harvest, and just the usual challenging staffing issues, this program seems like another alphabet soup regulation that came out of nowhere.
Some owners are waiting to see how the lawsuits turn out. Others figure that if the state wants something, it’ll send a letter.
Unfortunately, being unaware does not remove an obligation.
The short answer: CalRecycle has the authority to fine a winery up to $50,000 per day, per violation, for not registering or not filing. Fines aren’t automatic, and we haven’t heard of any fines yet. But the lawsuits haven’t paused anything, the first deadlines have passed, and wineries are easy for the state to find. The best move is to register, or apply for your exemption, now.
In this post, you’ll learn:
• Why the EPR Program feels like it came out of nowhere (it didn’t)
• What the lawsuits are about, and why they don’t change your deadlines
• The deadlines you may have missed, and the one that’s coming
• What the penalties are, and how they’d start
• Your first step, whether you’re under or over $1 million in California sales
If you’re new to the EPR Program, start with our overview, EPR for Wineries: Start Here.
The EPR Program didn’t come out of nowhere
EPR stands for Extended Producer Responsibility. The idea is that businesses that put packaging into the market help pay for what happens to it afterward.
EPR Programs have actually been in play for over 30 years. Germany started one for packaging in 1991, and several Canadian provinces have run them for years. The larger wineries that ship internationally have teams and consultants in place to handle the required reporting.
California passed SB 54 in 2022 and set up its EPR Program and a timeline. Larger wineries rolled the new rules into their existing programs. CalRecycle began developing regulations and held many public meetings from 2023 through 2025. The CAA (the Circular Action Alliance, the organization CalRecycle approved to manage the reporting and collect the fees) began registering companies in 2025. So when the final regulations took effect in May 2026, the folks who already knew about EPR rules were prepared to submit their data.
Many small wineries that sell only in the United States may not have encountered the EPR Program until the final regulations took effect last May. It’s as though they weren’t invited to the party but still had to send a gift.
Why you may not have heard about it
The Wine Institute has followed the EPR Program closely. It sent members alerts about the reporting deadlines, the lawsuits, and the CAA’s program plan, which it reviewed and planned to comment on. One alert put it plainly: wine bottles covered by CRV are excluded, but wineries may still have obligations for secondary and tertiary packaging, like boxes and pallet wrap.
But those alerts went out through the member portal, not as public press releases. Its EPR page isn’t in the website’s menus (you have to search for it), and it links to the CAA and CalRecycle without much else. Unless you were a Wine Institute member who also knew to look for this legislation, you may not have heard much.
The compliance companies that help wineries keep up with shipping rules rely on updates from the TTB and the ABC. This program came through California’s environmental and waste regulations, and those weren’t on their bingo card.
Is SB 54 being challenged?
Last updated October 6, 2026
Yes. Several groups have filed lawsuits against parts of the program. As of October 2026, the two you’ll hear about most are:
• A group of environmental organizations that says the final regulations aren’t strict enough. They want the rules revised, not thrown out.
• 17 states and a national wholesalers’ association that want a federal court to block the law. A hearing on their request is scheduled for January 15, 2027.
You may also have read that a judge blocked a California recycling law this summer. That was SB 343, which covers the recycling symbol on packaging. It’s a different law.
The lawsuits have not changed the filing and payment requirements that apply to your winery.
No court has paused SB 54. Until one does, the deadlines stand. And if you wait and the lawsuits fail, you’ll be even further behind.
For a list of all the lawsuits, check out the Litigation Watch section at www.epratlas.com. It’s a free website maintained by a packaging and sustainability consultant with over 20 years of experience in the EPR world. It’s also a useful way to see which other states are developing EPR Programs.
Forbes recently published an article that does a good job explaining why EPR Programs exist and what’s happening with the court cases.
These are the deadlines and your to-do list
• Register with the CAA: due June 1, 2026
• Submit the 2026 Baseline Producer Report (2023 data): due May 31, 2026 (accepted through June 1, because May 31 fell on a Sunday)
• Submit the 2026 Annual Supply Report (2025 data): due May 31, 2026
• Submit the 2026 Annual Source Reduction Report (2025 data): due May 31, 2026
• Submit the Individual Source Reduction Plan: due August 1, 2026
• Pay California Early Fees: due within 45 days of the CAA’s invoice (after filing the 2026 Annual Supply Report)
These are posted on the CAA’s 2026 EPR Producer Report Planning page. If the report names are new to you, our post California EPR Reports for Wineries, Translated into Plain English explains each one.
And the next deadline is already on the calendar. The 2027 reports, using your 2026 data, are due May 31, 2027. The packaging and sales records you keep this year are the ones you’ll report next spring.
If you’re under $1 million in California sales
Wineries with less than $1 million in California gross sales may apply for the Small Producer Exemption. THIS IS SUPER IMPORTANT.
• You must apply for the exemption. The deadline to apply was June 1, 2026.
• You must re-apply every 2 years, or register with the CAA if your California sales go over $1 million.
• The exemption is effective on the date it’s approved.
Create a CalRecycle WebPass account, register in PEPRS (CalRecycle’s online system), then submit the Small Producer Exemption application. You’ll find it on CalRecycle: Exemptions for Small Producers.
Until you receive your exemption, small producers are subject to the deadlines.
The paperwork is straightforward. If your total sales on your tax return were under $1 million, you can submit the return. If your total sales were $1 million or more, you’ll need more documentation to show your California sales were below the threshold. (Your CDTFA sales tax return may not be enough on its own. If you reported out-of-state distributor sales as “sales for resale,” the return lumps them in with your California sales.)
Our post Is Your Winery Exempt from California EPR? walks you through what counts and how to prove it.
There could be penalties
SB 54 gives CalRecycle the authority to impose administrative penalties of up to $50,000 per day, per violation. For a qualifying small producer, the maximum is $25,000 per day, per violation.
A few things to know:
• These are maximums, not automatic fines. For a first violation that isn’t egregious, the law tells CalRecycle to consider a penalty of no more than $25,000 per day.
• Penalties start after a notice. They can begin accruing 30 days after the winery receives a Notice of Violation.
• “Per violation” adds up. Missing your registration and four reports could count as five separate violations.
• There may be a way back. Before assessing penalties, CalRecycle can allow a producer to submit a corrective action plan to fix the problem.
Here’s what we know so far. At least one winery that registered with the CAA has received a notice about its missing reports. It wasn’t threatening, but it’s a sign the clock is ticking. We don’t yet know whether wineries that haven’t registered at all will be contacted.
If you missed a deadline, take steps to register or file now rather than waiting for a notice.
Don’t count on staying under the radar
Wineries that make or sell wine in California are already known to CalRecycle through the CRV program, and to the ABC through your license. Other businesses, like those that sell branded candles, cosmetics, or specialty foods, could be EPR producers without ever having registered with CalRecycle. Wineries don’t have that luxury. So, to quote the great Stephen Colbert (we miss you, Late Show): You are known.
The EPR Program is separate from the CRV program and has different obligations, but CalRecycle manages both. It’s like the DMV: you can register your car and get a driver’s license through the same agency, but completing one doesn’t complete the other.
Your next steps
The very first step is one of these:
• Under $1 million in California gross annual sales: Register in PEPRS, CalRecycle’s online system, and apply for the Small Producer Exemption. Read our blog Is Your Winery Exempt?
or
• $1 million or more in California gross annual sales: Register with the CAA and complete the reports that apply to you.
Your next step is to figure out how to put the EPR Program into practice. The work includes:
Identify your packaging and what it’s made of.
Run sales reports by SKU and by “ship to” state, across every channel (tasting room, wine club, eCommerce, and wholesale).
Calculate the weight of the packaging material on what you sold into each state.
Keep an eye on the other EPR states you ship to.
Missing a filing deadline doesn’t mean a penalty appears automatically. Find out what your winery needs to file, gather your packaging and sales information, and take the next step now, even if you’re already late.
You have several options for getting this done
DIY: Read the regulations and prepare the reports yourself.
CalRecycle Producer Guidance – start here for the agency’s explanations and reporting guidance
CalRecycle’s final SB 54 regulations – the actual rules
CalRecycle small producer exemptions – for wineries consider that application
CAA reporting resources and deadlines – for wineries reporting through CAA
Self-help: Our EPR for Wineries – Guide + Workbook does the hard part for you: the guide translates California’s EPR rules into just what a winery needs to know, and the workbook and video walkthroughs take you through the calculations. With your packaging and sales data in hand, you could be done in a few hours.
Outside help: Search “EPR help” and compare providers. Some charge $10,000 or more, so ask about both the price and the work you’ll still have to do yourself.
Frequently asked questions
Will I be fined automatically if I missed a deadline?
No. Penalties are a maximum CalRecycle may impose, and they can’t start accruing until 30 days after a Notice of Violation. But waiting makes the problem harder to fix.
Should I wait for the lawsuits to be decided?
No. As of October 2026, no court has paused SB 54, and the deadlines still apply.
I’m under $1 million in California sales. Do I still need to do anything?
Yes. The exemption isn’t automatic. Until CalRecycle approves your application, you’re treated like any other producer.
I missed the 2026 deadlines. Is it too late?
No. Register with the CAA, or apply for the Small Producer Exemption, as soon as you can. Then start gathering your packaging and sales information for the reports that are late. The 2027 reports will be due soon (May 31, 2027) and you will still have to file the 4 reports that were due in 2026.
The 30-second recap
• The deadlines are real, even with the lawsuits. No court has paused SB 54.
• CalRecycle can fine you up to $50,000 a day per violation ($25,000 if you qualify as a small producer), starting 30 days after a notice.
• Your first step this week is to apply for the Small Producer Exemption or register with the CAA, whichever applies to you.
Where to go next
Get EPR updates? Sign up for our newsletter where we share EPR updates and other information useful for the small wineries.
Ready to get it done? Our EPR for Wineries – Guide + Workbook translates California’s EPR rules into just what a winery needs to know, and the workbook does the math for you. With your packaging and sales data in hand, open a bottle of wine, and you will be finished in no time.
New to the EPR Program? Read EPR for Wineries: Start Here for the full overview and the 8-step roadmap.
Coming next: How Much Will EPR Fees Cost Your Winery? How the Fees Are Calculated and What Data You’ll Need (coming soon)
Once you’ve gotten over the shock of the reporting side of this program, your next question is probably: what will the EPR fees be? In the next post, we’ll look at how California’s EPR fees are calculated and how to build them into your overhead budget.
About the author: Jeanette Tan is the founder of QB Winery Solutions. She has worked exclusively with small wineries for over 15 years and has taught at Sonoma State’s Wine Business Institute.
Disclaimer: QB Winery Solutions is not a law firm or regulatory compliance company. This information is intended to be educational and is not legal advice. EPR rules and deadlines are still changing; this post reflects what we know as of the "Posted" date above. Confirm material classifications, exemptions, and reporting obligations with your attorney, compliance professional, vendors, and the applicable state program.